Oklahoma State beat Oregon on Saturday with a roster it had rebuilt in ten months.

Sixty-six transfers in. Sixty-four out. Eighteen of the arrivals followed the head coach from North Texas.

Four other programs had a cycle just as far from the norm. No two for the same reason.

This week's read

The piece below is the first in a new series we are calling The Ledger, our count of what the portal actually did, taken from the network's own record.

Three weeks into the season the depth charts are set and the portal is quiet until January, so we counted every completed transfer the network recorded, in and out, at the five programs that sat furthest outside their peers this cycle: Oklahoma State, Temple, Charlotte, Dartmouth and Virginia. Counted on September 15. Between them, 321 players moved. 156 in, 165 out. It is a long read. Pour something.

Put those five side by side and the totals start to look like the same event. They are not. A firing in September explains one of them. A second-year staff's plan explains two more. A league rule explains the fourth. An 11-win season explains the fifth. None of it happened on the field.

It is easier to see in one person than in a column. Jaxon Smolik left Penn State for Temple without having thrown a pass there, and on Saturday he played against Penn State and broke off the longest run of his career. Vasean Washington started eight games at right tackle for Dartmouth last season, then graduated in March with a year of eligibility the Ivy League only lets him use somewhere else. He is at Ohio State now.

The market moved

The rulebook bill cleared its first Senate hurdle last night. On September 15 the Senate voted to invoke cloture on the motion to proceed to the Protect College Sports Act, clearing the 60-vote threshold, and the Senate returns on September 16 to continue consideration of the motion to proceed. Three weeks ago in this newsletter, that vote was still waiting on the Senate's September return. So what: the January board you start building next month may be built under a different rulebook than the one you are working under today, and the staffs that wrote their triggers down in August will read that news rather than react to it.

The Toolbox

A transfer total is the start of the question, not the answer.

1. Count both columns. Charlotte ranked near the top of the departures board in early September, and that is usually where people stop reading. It also ranked high on arrivals. Sixty players moved through that roster in ten months, and the second number changes what the first one means.

2. Ask what level they came from and where they went. A player who leaves for a program a level up and a player who leaves for a program two levels down are the same row in a total and opposite facts about a roster.

3. Put the record next to it. Of the five programs in this week's piece, the heaviest departure column belongs to the one that just beat a top-10 team. The column on its own told you nothing about any of them.

Get the full count, level by level, and what was going on at each program: Why five programs moved 321 players through the portal

The trusted takeaway

Every one of those 321 rows was a decision somebody made. A coach choosing between the players he already knows and the best ones available to him. A player choosing whether the next step is about snaps, level, a degree, or a staff he already trusts.

None of that reasoning is in the record. The count is.

This is five programs out of hundreds. The Ledger will keep counting.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate